As electric vehicles (EVs) gain momentum, two standout models in the compact SUV segment are the MG Windsor EV and the Tata Punch EV. Both cars come packed with advanced features, safety systems, and eco-friendly technologies, making them ideal options for urban drivers and eco-conscious individuals. However, each car offers distinct advantages, catering to different preferences. In this comparison, we will delve into the specifications and features of both vehicles to help buyers determine which one best suits their needs.

Battery and Performance

The MG Windsor EV comes equipped with a 38 kWh battery that uses prismatic cells with liquid cooling, delivering a range of 332 km on the MIDC cycle. This vehicle supports multiple charging modes, with a charging time of 13.8 hours via a 3.3 kW charger and 6.5 hours with a 7.4 kW charger. Fast charging at 50 kW takes just 55 minutes to reach 80%. Its Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor produces 136 PS of power and 200 Nm of torque, offering driving modes such as Eco+, Eco, Normal, and Sports. This combination makes the MG Windsor EV powerful and versatile, allowing drivers to tailor the driving experience based on their preferences and road conditions.

On the other hand, the Tata Punch EV is available in two variants, offering a 25 kWh or 35 kWh battery. The range for the Punch EV is 265 km, while the Punch EV LR boasts an extended range of 365 km. The smaller battery variant produces 60 kW of power and 114 Nm of torque, while the larger battery version generates 90 kW of power and 190 Nm of torque. The Punch EV takes 9.4 hours to charge fully using a standard 15A socket, with faster options available via a 7.2 kW AC charger or a 50 kW DC fast charger, which can charge the battery to 80% in 56 minutes. The Tata Punch EV offers multi-drive modes, including Eco, City, and Sport, with regenerative braking technology for improved efficiency.

While both cars offer solid performance, the MG Windsor EV provides higher torque and power output, making it ideal for those who need more robust performance on the road. However, the Tata Punch EV LR offers a better range, which may appeal to drivers looking for extended travel distances between charges.

Dimensions

The MG Windsor EV is a larger vehicle compared to the Tata Punch EV, which could be an important consideration for buyers who need more cabin and cargo space. The Windsor EV measures 4295 mm in length, 1850 mm in width (2126 mm with mirrors), and 1677 mm in height, with a wheelbase of 2700 mm. It offers an impressive boot space of 604 liters in its Excite and Exclusive variants, while the Essence variant provides 579 liters of cargo space. This makes the MG Windsor EV ideal for families or those needing extra room for luggage or equipment.

In contrast, the Tata Punch EV is more compact, with a length of 3857 mm, a width of 1742 mm, and a height of 1633 mm. Its wheelbase is 2445 mm, and it offers a more modest 366 liters of boot space. While the Punch EV is smaller and more agile, making it well-suited for city driving and navigating tight spaces, it falls short in terms of overall interior space and cargo capacity compared to the Windsor EV. However, the Tata Punch EV’s ground clearance of 190 mm is slightly higher than the Windsor’s 186 mm, giving it an edge for those who may encounter rough or uneven terrains.

Exterior Features

In terms of exterior styling, the MG Windsor EV stands out with its modern and luxurious design. It features R17 or R18 diamond-cut alloy wheels, LED projector headlamps, and illuminated logos that add a premium touch. The smart flush door handles and chrome finish on the window beltline further enhance its upscale appearance. The larger wheel options and overall design give the Windsor EV a more commanding presence on the road.

The Tata Punch EV, while not as large or flashy, also sports a stylish exterior. Higher variants offer LED headlamps, sequential front indicators, and R16 diamond-cut alloy wheels. The Punch EV’s compact design makes it more suitable for urban environments, and it includes features like electric ORVMs with auto-fold functionality and a shark-fin antenna for a modern look. Both vehicles offer attractive styling, but the MG Windsor EV is more geared toward buyers seeking a premium, high-end feel, whereas the Tata Punch EV is perfect for those preferring a more subtle and practical design.

Interior Features

Inside, the MG Windsor EV continues to shine with luxury appointments. It offers two infotainment screen options: a massive 15.6-inch display in the Exclusive variant and a 10.1-inch display in other variants. Both support wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay, making it easy to connect and manage mobile devices. The Windsor EV also offers ambient lighting with 256 color options, 9 speakers with a subwoofer, and ventilated front seats. The 135° multi-level recline rear seats and 6-way power adjustable driver seat add to the comfort, making it an excellent choice for long drives.

The Tata Punch EV comes with a 26.03 cm HD infotainment system by HARMAN in higher variants and offers wireless smartphone connectivity via Android Auto and Apple CarPlay. The Punch EV also features ventilated front seats, an air purifier with an AQI display, and a 26.03 cm digital cockpit in higher trims, which gives it a more tech-forward feel. Although not as spacious or luxurious as the Windsor EV, the Punch EV’s interior is practical and includes modern amenities that make it competitive in its segment.

Safety Features

When it comes to safety, both vehicles are well-equipped. The MG Windsor EV includes 6 airbags (dual front, side, and curtain), all four disc brakes, and advanced safety systems like electronic stability program (ESP), hill start assist, and hill descent control. It also features ISOFIX child seat anchors, 360° surround-view cameras, and rain-sensing wipers, making it a secure option for families.

The Tata Punch EV also offers 6 airbags, electronic stability program (ESP), and ISOFIX child seat anchors. The higher variants include advanced features like a 360° surround-view camera system and a blind-spot view monitor, adding an extra layer of safety. Notably, the Punch EV has a BNCAP 5-star safety rating, giving buyers extra confidence in its crashworthiness.

Both cars score high on safety, but the Tata Punch EV gains an edge with its BNCAP rating and additional safety features in the higher variants, making it a solid option for safety-conscious buyers.

Charging and Connectivity

The MG Windsor EV comes with a 3.3 kW portable charger and an optional 7.4 kW AC home charger. It supports fast charging, allowing the battery to reach 80% in just 55 minutes using a 50 kW DC charger. The Windsor EV also boasts i-SMART features, enabling voice commands, remote car control, and live location sharing via the i-SMART app. Entertainment features such as JioSaavn and OTTplay streaming services are also integrated, making the Windsor EV a tech-savvy choice for modern drivers.

The Tata Punch EV supports multiple charging options, including a portable 15A socket, a 7.2 kW AC fast charger, and a 50 kW DC fast charger, which charges the battery to 80% in 56 minutes. The Punch EV’s ZConnect app provides vehicle status updates, live tracking, and smartwatch connectivity, enhancing its connectivity capabilities. Additionally, higher variants include an entertainment suite through the Arcade.ev app and support for multiple voice assistants like Tata’s “Hey Tata,” Alexa, Siri, and Google Assistant.

Both vehicles offer robust charging and connectivity features, but the MG Windsor EV edges ahead with its entertainment options and i-SMART platform, providing a more comprehensive in-car experience.

Conclusion

The MG Windsor EV and Tata Punch EV both bring a lot to the table, but they cater to slightly different audiences. The MG Windsor EV stands out with its luxury, spaciousness, and premium features, making it an ideal choice for those looking for a high-end electric vehicle with plenty of room and a sophisticated design. On the other hand, the Tata Punch EV is more compact, practical, and tech-focused, appealing to buyers who prioritize efficiency, advanced safety features, and connectivity options in a smaller footprint.

Ultimately, the MG Windsor EV is the right pick for those who want a more upscale driving experience, while the Tata Punch EV offers practicality, efficiency, and advanced technology in a more compact and cost-effective package. Your choice will depend on whether you prioritize luxury and space or tech-forward features and affordability in your electric vehicle.